Thayr on Nostr: Not even based on a narration from the prophet pbuh himself they rely on one main ...

Not even based on a narration from the prophet pbuh himself they rely on one main narrator in an old age through a narrator who was known to have issues in narration in old age. The first narrator Aisha pbuh said that narration in an old age contradictory to her other narrations in a younger age and other narrations and historical facts, etc. She was at badr battle and the prophet pbuh prohibits anyone under 15 to enter battle as is the examples of Abdullah ibn Omar and Osama ibn Zayd and others. no one is at war at younger than 15 and she has her older sister Asmaa with a known age (birthdate and deathdate) between them exactly ten years, also the clear contradiction to the Qur'an about the age of marriage when talking as an example about the orphans that after their puberty we have to wait and see if they are mature or not to give them their money/, etc.